Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tom Joad's avatar

Why I Wrote "No Más"

I wrote this story because I'm exhausted by a particular kind of silence.

Not the silence of people who have nothing to say, but the silence of people who have been taught that speaking will get them killed. The silence that gets mistaken for acceptance. The silence that systems of violence depend on to sustain themselves.

For years, I've watched a generation come of age in contexts where staying quiet was framed as wisdom, where keeping your head down was called survival, where acceptance of the unacceptable was repackaged as pragmatism. And I've watched that same generation begin to reject that equation entirely.

This story isn't journalism,it's a thought experiment about what happens when a generation realizes that the "safety" their parents bought with silence wasn't safety at all. It's about the moment when people understand that acceptance is just death in slow motion, and that the cage was never actually locked.

Why It Matters

Because acceptance is always political. When we accept violence as inevitable, corruption as unchangeable, or death as "just how things are," we're not being realistic,we're participating in the system that produces those outcomes. The youth in this story understand something profound: the system survives because people accept it. Take away acceptance, and the entire structure becomes unstable.

Because every generation inherits the compromises of the last. The parents in this story aren't villains. They made rational choices in impossible circumstances. They stayed quiet because speaking up got people killed. They paid the protection money because refusing meant death. They taught their children to survive because they loved them. But those survival strategies, multiplied across millions of people over decades, became the foundation that made continued violence possible.

Because documentation changes everything. One of the most important threads in this story is Río and the digital infrastructure. The youth aren't braver than their parents,they have tools their parents never had. They can document. They can encrypt. They can distribute evidence faster than it can be destroyed. They can make it impossible to forget. That changes the calculus of resistance entirely.

Because questions can be more powerful than demands. Camila's question,”Why is wanting to stay alive treated like rebellion?",cuts through every layer of complexity and excuse. It names the foundational absurdity of systems that require citizens to accept their own deaths. It's not a policy proposal. It's not a negotiating position. It's a question that can't be answered without admitting what everyone already knows.

What I Hope Readers Take From This

This story is about Mexico, but it's not only about Mexico. It's about any context where violence has been normalized, where corruption has been institutionalized, where fear has become background noise.

It's about the moment when people stop asking "Can we win?" and start asking "Can we live with ourselves if we don't try?"

It's about understanding that realistic often just means accepting the unacceptable, and that being called naive by people who've spent decades managing decline might actually be a sign you're onto something.

It's about the power of refusal,not refusal backed by force or ideology, just the simple, absolute refusal to treat murder as normal.

The Bigger Picture

We're living through a moment when young people around the world are looking at systems that have been presented as inevitable and asking: Why? Why this way? Why not something else?

They're not asking politely. They're not waiting for permission. They're not calculating odds or conducting cost-benefit analyses. They're just refusing to accept frameworks that treat their deaths as acceptable losses.

That refusal is its own kind of power. It doesn't guarantee victory. It doesn't make the fight easier. But it changes what's possible by changing what's acceptable.

The youth in this story understand something that often takes older generations decades to learn: you don't need permission to stop accepting the unacceptable. You don't need a perfect plan or guaranteed success. You just need to stop pretending that normal is acceptable when normal is killing you.

That's why I wrote this. Because I wanted to capture that moment of refusal. That instant when acceptance breaks and something else becomes possible.

Whether it's enough, whether it works, whether they win,that's not the point. The point is they're trying. They're refusing. They're showing up.

And sometimes, that's where everything starts.

If this resonated with you, I'd love to hear why. And if you think others need to read it, share it. Stories about refusal need to travel.

https://open.substack.com/pub/joadt/p/no-mas?r=5ccpro&utm_medium=ios

GREGG PLAPAS's avatar

As always, great article Tom.

Mexico is in a gawd awful situation with the cartels, and has been for decades. Not to mention that our own US Government aided and abetted these same cartels, who continue to evolve with youth, that has the same capabilities if not more, then the brave protesters you write about here.

How does a country or for that matter a hemisphere, eradicate this murderous disease these cartels have become?

I wish I had the answer……..

Is Trump right to use our military? Maybe, but to what end, at what cost, and what is driving his real interest…..OIL?

While reading your article I could not help but think about our own youth here in the US.

41 million members of Generation Z were eligible to vote in the 2024 presidential election. But, the few who actually took the time to vote, voted for Trump!

I see that as the same “acceptance” the elders had in your article but, to one man, not a cartel. Which in my eyes is even worse. Normalizing Trump is the same acceptance.

My hope is that Gen Z has finally seen the light in that Trump & the Republicans have sold them, as well as the rest of the country a bill of goods, not worth the paper it was documented on, and will finally put an end to their chaos by voting en masse in all of our upcoming & future elections.

RESIST !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

18 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?